
PREAMBLE
Man, have I been waiting to write this review.
I remember when I first heard Alice in Chains – it was 1997, and someone at my school lent me a mixtape of several bands (that also included Pearl Jam), the opening two tracks on side A of which were Them Bones and Dam That River. I knew I had hit something that resonated, because I couldn’t stop singing the two tunes whenever I was away from my cassette deck.
And 12 years later I still can’t.
Maybe I was very green at the time, but I hadn’t heard a band do those kinds of rhythms before, not in metal or grunge. On top of that, over the thundering snarl of what should have been a “metal” song came this ethereal fallen angel voice of a man I was destined never to see live, the band’s leader Layne Staley. And the harmonies, twisted and made possible by guitarist and secondary singer and main song-writing force Jerry Cantrell. Together they were the haunted, warped version of that “frontman/lead guitarist” relationship worn by Lennon and McCartney, Jagger and Richards, you know the drill, the list goes on.
Staley’s death in 2002 was discovered three days after my birthday. I still have his obituary torn out of the Daily Telegraph somewhere.
And so, I thought, I would never be around for a new Chains release, that I’d have to just be (very) happy with their back catalogue, Staley’s only other complete (and awesome) album Mad Season and follow Jerry’s solo work, which I liked, but it had to be said, not as much as Jar of Flies, Dirt et al.
Then nothing.
But since the 2005 Tsunami concert momentum has built – first William DuVall joined the band full-time after touring previously in Cantrell’s support – and when in 2008 Alice announced after extensive touring that a new album was on the way, it seemed that the fans, at least the ones who write on the net, were supportive (read “insanely giddy at the prospect”) of a new Chains album, even with dear departed Layne out of the picture.
In August Listening party reports started hitting the net – overwhelmingly positive. Skeptical fans reserved their judgement – which was fair enough. Staley’s vocals have been often imitated (almost always poorly by the likes of Puddle of Mudd, “Worst Band In The World” Creed, Nickelback, mid-to-late-era Stone Temple Pilots, Days of the New and Godsmack whose name is even taken from a song on Dirt) – the last thing they wanted to see was a goddamned imitator IN Alice in Chains itself.
This video pretty much explains what the fans were worries about:
So to the album…
ALBUM REVIEW
As if to reference their member-by-member entry onto the stage at the MTV Unplugged show where they left off in 1996, the opener All Secrets Known is a jabby muted Cantrell riff, slowly joined by bass, then drums, then finally Staley.
Hope
A New Beginning
Time…
Time to start living
like just before we die.
There’s no going back to the place
We started from…
OK OK it’s NOT Staley. But it might as well be…DuVall’s voice must be the only one in existence that can fill Staley’s shoes. And it’s thanks to the good luck of Jerry and co that they found him out of 6 billion people. Because as the voice slowly fills the landscape, and a harmonized chorus of layered voices including Cantrell’s crescendo out and expand, you start wondering why the fuck we can’t have more music like this all the time.
The album balances slow “pretty music that makes you want to die” as drummer Sean Kinney once said quoted in Staley’s obituary with more acoustic fare, with some songs like Acid Bubble deliberately splicing very heavy with very light, and flicking the switch between them and making you fall out of your seat and fumble for the tracklist to see if you’re onto the next song yet.
INTENT OBSOLESCENCE
BUILT INTO THE SYSTEM!
Now it has to be said that some parts of the album are a little weak. Your Decision, destined for radio release soon, is surprisingly conventional compared with what wonderous acoustic beauty we had on Jar of Flies. And while most of Last of My Kind is incredible, one lyric about “fucking liars” is so surprisingly out of place (the band have always impressed me with their vocal quality, which happened not to include swear-words) that it feels like the album is about to take a turn for the worse .
By far the strongest tracks are the already released Check My Brain, a bendy semi-tone scaled snake of a track, and A Looking in View, an 804 minute epic featuring some of the best riffs in Chains’ career. Add to that the opener, and my personal favourite Private Hell – listen to this whilst looking at the album art-work of the mother and daughter on a moonscape and I swear you can feel the cold desolate atmosphere creep in – wonderful lilting echoed “Uh-Huh”s and subtle key-changes make this the star track on the album and put’s it in my five favourite Alice songs.
I excuse myself I’m used to my little cell
I amuse myself in my very own private hell…
Something about the riffs and tight harmonized DuVall/Cantrell partnership draws contemplation out of the listener. It’s currently on repeat anywhere I go. And no you can’t play your own music in “your own house”, not now that we have this. Move over.
The final track, the eponymous track with Elton John subtly on piano, and the first overtly Staley-related song the band have made, is the hardest to listen to emotionally; especially if you’ve watched the Electronic Press Kit Video Alice released a few hours ago. Members of the band were breaking down in tears, Kinney describes a panic attack that gripped him and reduced him to sitting on a bathroom floor, and Cantrell suffered a three-week migraine brought on by “undigested grief” after he had penned the ballad.
Show me ANY song in mainstream music that has that much emotional weight behind it. Yeah, thought not.
Black Gives Way To Blue is a band wearing it’s heart on its sleeve, as the cover subtly implies. The brutal bitter-sweet Alice in Wonderland vibe is still there, preserved in the mock-Victorian art-work, filthy guitars, Kinney’s fantastic tasteful breakbeat drumming, Mike Inez’s distant thunder detuned “bass of death” and Cantrell’s enviable song-writing skill topped off with those harmonic vocals. A storming success with a few minor hiccups. To be honest the first thing I thought once I had heard this album once through was;
“Man, when are they going to release the next one?”
Until then, I have a new set of songs to have on repeat.




14 comments
Comments feed for this article
September 23, 2009 at 5:58 pm
Charlie McIntosh
Rolling Stone doesn’t know what they’re doing when they give this album 2 stars and shove three paragraphs in the back of the rag.
This is a great review. I actually hadn’t seen the press kit that was put out until this morning and yeah, AIC has still got it.
I’m really looking forward to an Acoustic EP!
September 23, 2009 at 8:54 pm
hypernation
Thanks Charlie! Glad you enjoyed reading like I enjoyed finally writing it. I hadn’t seen that Rolling Stone article. What absolute heathens! Is there a definite acoustic coming out? We definitely need a third acoustic EP, just to have a trio.
September 25, 2009 at 8:05 am
Robert C
Most of your review was well thought out. I say most of because of the mention of that list of bands whose vocalists try to imitate Layne…no they don’t. None of them would be dumb enough to even try. People just inheritantly want to compare one band to another band, it’s human nature.
i.e. Godsmack. Sounds like it’s time to update you on why they chose that for their bands name. Here is the response from Sully…
Sully Erna: Our definition of Godsmack is “instant karma”. My drummer came into rehearsal one day before we were signed with a huge cold sore on his lip, and I made fun of him all day. The next day, I had a huge cold sore on MY lip; exact same size and spot. My guitarist said, “see, God just smacked you for making fun of him”. That’s what our band name means — what goes around comes around.
As for Alice’ new album you describe it well. I too was surprised when hearing the ‘F’ word, too bad it was used. I also enjoyed that their music historically doesn’t have curse words, thankfully it’s minimal. You ask why can’t we have more music like this? This is one band that oozes originality, it just can’t be mimicked. That list of bands you mention doesn’t sound like AIC. Jerry’s a 6 string master, very few in the world are like him. Creed shouldn’t have even been mentioned…good grief man, those twacks belong in the toilet.
It is uncannny how tight Duvall and Cantrell sing together on the track Private Hell…it sounds like vintage AIC with the exception of Jerry being the lead instead of Layne. I don’t think Duvall oversteps his boundries anywhere on the album either, I agree with you, he really is the only guy in the world that could pull this off. A rare find he is.
Chances are this album will be well received by listeners who appreciate well written Rock, not the shit they put on the radio that is simply background noise. AIC’s music has always been the kind of music that pierces the mind and is in a class of its own.
This album was a pleasant surprise. Rock really needed this, too much crap out there.
Well done AIC
September 25, 2009 at 12:00 pm
hypernation
Robert – many thanks for your comment and compliments, you have submitted something very rare, a well-expressed and thought-out comment.
I do agree with you that the bands I list are awful – that was my point. There is no doubt, however, that Layne’s unique style was wholesale exported by the less talented (including The Worst Band in the World) – and while I appreciate Sully Erna’s comments, they are rather irrelevant – Godsmack began as an AIC tribute band – and as with many tribute bands, they lifted their name from a song. I am interested to see his comments about God, considering he’s a practising Wickan, though.
Your comments about Private Hell are right on, too. The balance of Duvall’s and Cantrell’s vocal lines in the album mix are very carefully tipped in favour of Cantrell, mostly because it’s a gentle way to introduce that hardest of product modofications – a new singer. In time I imagine the balance will shift in favour of Duvall – the fans seem to be asking for it.
Enjoy the album, and I hope you catch them live – I’m seeing them in November and can’t wait.
September 26, 2009 at 2:23 pm
GroggyFroggy
DuVall fits in well, but honest to God, if I had to pick one contemporary rock singer who could do the best job of replacing Staley, I would have to go with Chester Bennington. I think he sounds most like him, but then again, it’s highly possible that AIC doesn’t want a Staley imitator and that they want to go in an entirely new direction in that aspect. But for what it’s worth, just compare many Linkin Park songs to old AIC songs vocally (look for that high-pitched, guttural, harrowing scream, and of course the addiction-centered lyrics as well), and I think that you will find that those two are about as close to each other as Bon Scott and Brian Johnson.
September 26, 2009 at 3:34 pm
GDupont
Great review. I’m on my third listen to the CD and Acid Bubble has got me hooked. I’m looking at tour dates and then going to start calling in favors. I saw AIC open for Van (Hagar) Halen in 92 and all I knew at that time was Man In A Box – When they played “It Ain’t Like That” and “Bleed The Freak” I instantly became a fan and bought and downloaded everything I could.
I missed Alice. I’m glad your back. See you at the show.
RIP Layne – I hope you found peace.
September 28, 2009 at 8:15 am
hypernation
I Love Acid Bubble! They’ve been playing it live too. Very cool. Hope you get tickets!
October 7, 2009 at 12:13 am
GDupont
From Social Parasite – great early Alice.
You say you don’t like the way we look
Well fuck off
I ain’t some dying dog that you can kick
So fuck off
October 7, 2009 at 3:33 pm
hypernation
Yes, less good, that track, bit more glam metal era. But a valid point nonetheless.
September 28, 2009 at 7:02 am
karl
yeah i have to agree this is a very good review, and about the other one on Stuff.co.nz and Rollingstone does not do this album enough justice. Admittedly the band will not always appeal to others that like this type of music, but i discovered this band after getting sick of all the mainstream rock out there (read nirvana, etc).
Its about time this band got a lot more publicity than it does now, a lot of my mates have never heard of this before.
Hopefully with the Ozzie tour they decide to come to NZ. Hopefully….
KP
September 28, 2009 at 8:17 am
hypernation
Thanks for your kind words. If I were you I’d definitely make the trip across the pond to see Alice in Oz. They are sure to be back after their set at Soundwave earlier this year. I missed it by a few weeks.
I’ll nevertheless keep all my fingers crossed for you.
October 4, 2009 at 9:58 pm
Brain
Just to point out, several songs with Layne feature swearing. Just look at “Hate to Feel” and “God Am”:
“What the f— will it take? / Drown myself in my wake”
“Dear God, how have you been, man? / I’m not fine, f— pretending”
Otherwise a great review, and I wish people like you would write for those old media rags, rather than the douche bags at Spin and Rolling Stone. I remember Rolling Stone gave “Nevermind” by Nirvana a horrible review, then revised it to a perfect score once it sold 200 thousand million billion copies.
October 5, 2009 at 8:12 am
hypernation
You’re right Brain. One lyric I had in my mind as I was writing was from Man in the Box, “buried in my shit” – and since writing the above, I’ve come to think that Last of My Kind is one of the strongest tracks on the album, forming a “triptych of Kickass” that really gets the album going.
Let’s watch that Rolling Stone “review” and see if they rewrite it…
October 19, 2009 at 1:01 am
Gearhead
There’s a few old songs with swearing; Social Parasite was more up front about it while Heaven Beside You’s “That’s F-ed up” was hardly noticeable. I really thought their attitude was that they didn’t need them to make a point.
I’m not sweating the RS review; they gave Nevermind a low score and redid it when it got popular, no doubt they’ll pull it again.